About Monuments and History: Let’s Learn from the Confederate Memorial in Helena

Photo by Don Pogreba, 2015. Memento Park in Budapest
Shares

One of the most interesting places I’ve traveled over the past few years was Memento Park in Budapest, an open-air museum filled with the detritus of Soviet rule over Eastern Bloc countries. There’s nothing the Soviets seemed to enjoy more than depositing gigantic statues of heroic communist workers, soldiers, and statesmen all over the countries they ruled over and there was nothing the people of those countries seemed to enjoy more in the first days of their freedom than toppling those statues. Memento Park is a tourist sight constructed to display those fallen monuments and talk about the time when the people of Eastern European countries had little control over their destinies. As one of the architects of the site noted:

“This park is about dictatorship. And at the same time, because it can be talked about, described, built, this park is about democracy. After all, only democracy is able to give the opportunity to let us think freely about dictatorship.”

If you want to see a Soviet-era statue, this is one of the few places left where you can. In the capitals of former Soviet Bloc countries I visited, there are few of these statues on display other than some very complicated and contentious memorials to Soviet dead from World War 2. I saw empty pedestals and heard stories about how thrilled the people of Prague were when their statue of Stalin went down in the 1960s. Memento Park isn’t just a collection of Soviet oddities; it offers a full educational program about the era and, critically, the purpose of those statues when they were placed by the Soviets.

This summer, I had the opportunity to visit museums in Riga, Latvia, and Vilnius, Lithuania that were constructed on the site of buildings that had previously housed the KGB. As we toured through ruins where men and women had been jailed, beaten, tortured, and even killed, the guides offered both a series of facts about what had happened in those horrific rooms and conveyed the emotions of what it had been like for the people to live under those conditions. We learned about the horrors of the Nazi and Soviet occupation of the Baltic countries, all of us leaving with a much great appreciation for how the events of that time still reverberated in Latvian and Lithuanian society today.

Seeing those empty pedestals, viewing those massive statues, and reeling from the impact of the KGB cells and killing rooms made me even more appreciative of the importance of preserving history, something I’ve always believed in. We absolutely must never forget the terrible moments in our history both remind us of how horrific and inhuman human behavior can be.

Of course, we must preserve our history. Of course, we must, in a democracy, discuss our past. But the Confederate Memorial in Helena did neither. The Daughters of the Confederacy who placed it and hundreds of other memorials around the country were the ones in the business of causing us to forget, hoping that the placement of monuments that obscured the causes of the Civil War would transform our collective memory. And they largely succeeded in that agenda, as evidenced by those who somehow believe that the South was not primarily motivated by slavery despite the words of the very men who led the secession from our country.

Like Soviet statues designed to obscure the brutality of Communist rule and celebrate Soviet soldiers, these monuments served the aims of propaganda, not history.

It’s a red herring to suggest that the people who cheered the removal of the Confederate Memorial Fountain in Helena wanted to destroy history or forget it. Many of us believe that it should be preserved in a museum setting so that it can become a teaching tool, not only about the soldiers who died during the Civil War but about the efforts during the Jim Crow era to whitewash Confederate history. Placed in a museum, in an appropriate context and explained by historians who can dissect the fountain and its motives, the memorial can finally transform from a symbol of a dark time in our history to an educational tool that helps to explain it.

Having visited the Smithsonian National Museum of African American History & Culture this spring, I’m almost certain no one is calling for the removal of the slave quarters or Emmett Till’s casket from its hallways. No one wants to remove its displays of racist caricatures, minstrel shows, or lynchings because all of those are presented with context that explains what their purpose was.  None of that was ever in place at the Confederate Memorial at Hill Park and it seems unlikely that a plaque could ever have provided the context necessary to explain it.

The irony of those who celebrate an imagined, ahistorical version of Confederate history suggesting that others want to destroy history is tragically ill-informed. Citing Orwell, as some have while celebrating a piece of propaganda, is as darkly humorous as much of his writing and a tragic reminder that we need to do a better job of educating people about thought control and manipulation.

Let’s stop fighting about this monument and start learning from it, in context and with the guidance of experts.

The director of the Montana Historical Society expressed his concern about the potential loss of history with the removal of the fountain. Let’s hope he can be taken at his word and will offer to take and display the fountain in an exhibit that lets us learn about the Daughters of the Confederacy and the era in which they were constructing these memorials. Perhaps he can organize a fundraiser for the display, given the passionate regard for history that seemed to be lacking when funding for the Montana Historical Society’s funding was under debate this winter, but so on display this week.

Perhaps we can transform a debate that has become increasingly bitter and personal over the past week into a moment in our history we can one day celebrate, when the people of Helena came together to preserve their collective history together rather than letting another skirmish in the American cultural civil war divide us even further.

I’m ready to donate for a new exhibit. Let’s make it happen, Helena.

If you appreciate our efforts to hold Montana Republicans accountable and the independent journalism here at The Montana Post, please consider supporting our work with a small pledge.

About the author

Don Pogreba

Don Pogreba is an eighteen-year teacher of English, former debate coach, and loyal, if often sad, fan of the San Diego Padres and Portland Timbers. He spends far too many hours of his life working at school and on his small business, Big Sky Debate.

His work has appeared in Politico and Rewire.

In the past few years, travel has become a priority, whether it's a road trip to some little town in Montana or a museum of culture in Ísafjörður, Iceland.

6
Leave a Reply

avatar
5 Comment threads
1 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
5 Comment authors
Matthew SilverDrunks for DennyJim JonesNancy BleckHighPoint Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
Notify of
Pete Talbot
Admin

Excellent post, Don. I’ve had to walk back some of my earlier comments on the fountain. Since I like statuary, and since it was a fountain and not Robert E. Lee or Jefferson Davis, I said just get rid of the plaque that praised the Confederacy and replace it with an accurate historical description of the Jim Crow era. I mentioned this to my wife and she dismissed my suggestion. “You’re a white man,” she said (she’s part Blackfeet) “you have no idea what a symbol like that means to African-Americans or other minorities.” She is, as is oft the… Read more »

HighPoint
Guest
HighPoint

I’m conflicted about this Civil War Canon recently rededicated by the Park County Commission and displayed in front of the Livingston City-County Complex. What exactly is the Grand Army of the Republic? http://www.parkcounty.org/Canon-Display-Project-Information/

Jim Jones
Guest
Jim Jones

The Grand Army of the Republic was a fraternal society for ex union soldiers. I,m fairly sure it is inactive now since the death of the last member.

Nancy Bleck
Guest
Nancy Bleck

There is a gofundmepage for upcycling Helena’s statue.

Drunks for Denny
Guest
Drunks for Denny

The heck with making a new interpretive exhibit. I could care less. The bozos who run Helena had two years to come up with a lousy interpretive sign, and they could not do that.

How about replacing the fountain, liberal do-gooders? It was a great place for my dogs to get a drink while taking a walk around town on a hot summer day.

Put your money where your mouths are, progressives. Replace the fountain!

Matthew Silver
Guest
Matthew Silver

As a Historian, student of History, a Southerner and Veteran I understand both positions about your statue however I would like to point out a few Historical facts in my research that I think the good people of Montana need to know about in order to have all the information relevant to your monument. You have heard from the Native American Caucus and the Western Cultural Inc. foundation on their opinions of the monument. I have also quoted the President of the Western Cultural Inc. Dan Hall below but first let us go back and look at History and not… Read more »

Support Our Work!

Poll

What would be the most appropriate nickname for Matt Rosendale?

Follow Us on Twitter

Subscribe Via E-mail

0 /* ]]> */