A Story about Plagiarism

Shares

I’ve never told this story publicly, partially because I wasn’t blogging at the time and partially because I imagined someone knocking on my door and beating me to death for temporarily delaying his career. Now, thirteen years later, I assume it’s probably safe to tell the story.

Some early morning in June 2002, I was reading online about a new documentary that detailed the experiences of the 1972 US Men’s Olympic basketball team. For some reason, no doubt because I was avoiding completing debate research I should have been working on, I kept reading stories about the team—and the horrible officiating that cost them the gold medal. Somewhere about the fifteenth link, I noticed something odd: an online encyclopedia seemed to have the exact same language as the initial news column I had read, word for word. I went back to the original story in the Salt Lake Tribune, and there it was: a paragraph of about 180 words, 180 words that the reporter had lifted from the online source without attribution.

I was outraged: as an English teacher, I’d punished fourteen year-old students for similar infractions, and here was a reporter at a mid-major newspaper lifting online material for his column. So I fired off an e-mail to the editor of the Salt Lake Tribune, not expecting an answer.

A few weeks later, though, I received a large envelope from Salt Lake City. In it was the complete copy of the June 30 edition of the Tribune, which included this:

When a journalist breaches reader trust, even when it is unintentional, it affects the newspaper’s credibility. I loathe disciplining staff members in public, but we all are quasi-public figures when it comes to our work and there are certain transgressions in this business that require public discussion for a clean closure…. A byline attached to a piece of writing means the prose is original to the author. Period. There is no excuse for plagiarism, but reasons are cited: In a hurry . . . got sloppy . . . cut a corner . . . was careless . . . wasn’t thinking . . . meant to attribute, but forgot. In hardly any instance is plagiarism pre-meditated.

The reporter was put on probation, but by all appearances, has redeemed himself from this professional error and continued to work in journalism. I’ve never felt totally okay with what happened to him, as I didn’t want to do harm to a stranger, but I suspect that, having been caught plagiarizing relatively early in his career, he learned a valuable lesson.

That’s the thing about plagiarism: many people need a reminder that it’s wrong. Whether it’s noted historians, political candidates, high school students or journalists, the most valuable lesson one can learn about plagiarism may not even be ethical, but practical: if you do it, you could well be caught. So when I read newspaper stories in the Missoulian that are plagiarized and both contact the editor and write about without receiving a response, or when the Independent Record briefly plagiarizes my brilliant satire before making it disappear, I have to wonder if I shouldn’t hold my students to high standards of academic integrity, because surely it’s not fair to punish a ninth grader for something that some adults can get away with without any trouble at all, especially when those adults expressed such horrified indignation about someone else’s plagiarism in the past.

In the end, of course, I’ll keep checking for plagiarism. Sorry, kids. A writer’s words and ideas are her own, and better to learn that lesson when the punishment is little more than wounded pride and having to rewrite a paper.

If you appreciate our efforts to hold Montana Republicans accountable and the independent journalism here at The Montana Post, please consider supporting our work with a small pledge.
Join a discussion of this (and all of our post) at our Facebook community page.

About the author

Don Pogreba

Don Pogreba is an eighteen-year teacher of English, former debate coach, and loyal, if often sad, fan of the San Diego Padres and Portland Timbers. He spends far too many hours of his life working at school and on his small business, Big Sky Debate.

His work has appeared in Politico and Rewire.

In the past few years, travel has become a priority, whether it's a road trip to some little town in Montana or a museum of culture in Ísafjörður, Iceland.

2 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • I guess it totally depends on who is doing the plagiarizing…John Walsh used a lot of other people’s work, cited it poorly but did cite it, and was drummed out of politics probably forever. OTOH Ron Paul does this type of thing serially, does not cite, when caught denies and denies, then changes the subject. Then refuses to acknowledge that he even wrote/spoke on the topic or whatever and all the subservient media types drop it and go on until the next time…and there is always a next time…next week or next month. It has happened so often now it barely gets a mention any more. Different standards for the different sides of the political aisle…oh yeah! Makes me absolutely sick.

    It’s hard to justify punishing the kids for doing this. And I really resent the hell out of the educational institution that withdrew Walsh’s degree for what was just a very poorly written, lazily researched mid-term paper. Ron Paul should have his medical license revoked if the same standards were applied to him. But of course that will never happen. Stupid crap. Ugh!

    • Yeah, our outrage certainly does seem selective, doesn’t it?

      That’s why, now that I am a better teacher, my punishment is the worst of all: making them re-write a piece.

/* ]]> */