What Are the Roots of Support for Palestine?

Shares

Speaking of states that want independence but are currently being invaded, the Tamils are finally losing their decades long struggle for a state with little fanfare. The Sri Lankan government is moving to close down their last bases for armed resistance, of course at the cost of great hardship for the Tamil people. Indeed, the Tamil Tigers liberation army seems to be trapped and finally approaching complete defeat. As was expected, there was a huge outcry for a ceasefire and negotiation, as most nations of the world admit the need for an eventual two-state solution to the Tamil crisis. Oh wait, no, no there’s not. In fact, there is no such sentiment being expressed by anyone. I am not about to defend the Tamil Tigers, or even necessarily call for complete Tamil independence, but I fail to see how this conflict is substantially different from the one that has been raging in Israel. In fact, they have many similarities. Both involve religious differences, intervention by European colonialism, showdowns between terrorism and oppressive military force, thousands of deaths, etc. But no one, it seems, cares to speak up on behalf of the Tamil people despite the fact that by most of the justifications used for a Palestinian state, the Tamils are just as deserving.

I can see merits both for having these nations become independent states or in having them join the states they are part of under some sort of compromise. But I don’t see any reason for two different treatment of the two. That is, unless you count the Palestinian´s sympathy among important Muslim nations a reason. And if one considers that the only reason we support the independence of one and not the other, then we should really stop the show of empathy for oppressed peoples and admit that we will continue to support the oppressed when it suits our needs, and turn the other way when it doesn’t. Anything else is disingenuous, transparent, and therefore a waste of breath.

There is of course another option: one can admit that public support for Palestine is largely due to international efforts to appease important Muslim nations (much as others have argued that support for Israel comes down to a desire to appease important Jewish minorities), but that it should rest on something a bit deeper, that is, a genuine concern for human dignity, a recognition that people should be allowed independence rather than having to submit to a different culture, etc. Adoption of this viewpoint would be admirable, but it requires more than supporting Palestine; it requires a coherent international policy philosophy that does not hold self interest as the highest goal; it requires really asking why Kosovo and Palestine, instead of Kurdistan, Tamil Eelam, or South Ossetia. Creating a system where international policy decisions are based primarily on soem defined sort of justice, not self interest, is an admirable goal. Sadly, it is contrary to almost every international policy decision or action undertaken in the last….ever.

If you appreciate our efforts to hold Montana Republicans accountable and the independent journalism here at The Montana Post, please consider supporting our work with a small pledge.

About the author

The Polish Wolf

9
Leave a Reply

avatar
9 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
7 Comment authors
gbeilqmkkhupjadwrjlvohjtjivjqjeuesxBunny Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
Notify of
Larry Kralj, Environmental Rangers!
Guest
Larry Kralj, Environmental Rangers!

Polish dog, you convoluted defense of israel is truly amazing. How do you do it? What’s missing in your screed is even a basic understanding of the history of the region. But here, how bout this? How bout we just stop slaughtering Muslims for awhile? ESPECIALLY with u.s. weapons of mass destruction. A century of colonial meddling has NOT won us any friends in the Middle East. Like in Latin America, our days are over. It’s time to butt out. And it’s also time to reign in fascist, racist israel. The creation of israel was HUGE mistake. The world is… Read more »

Liz
Guest
Liz

The “Holy Land” is the most contested piece of realty in the world – that’s probably why no one looks at the Tamil tigers… no one wants to live on an island that might be flooded by rising sea levels. I consider the holy land a lot less holy because of all the squabbling that has happened because of its mere existence. Before Roosevelt died, he talked with King Abdulaziz of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Because of the Saudis’ unfaltering (secret) support of the Americans during WWII, Roosevelt told the King in a letter that he would not vote… Read more »

Matt Downhour
Guest
Matt Downhour

Larry, I don´t doubt that you really feel for the Palestinians. But you feel for them probably because you actually hear about their plight, which no one is denying. And I wouldn´t deny them a state; frankly, I think the last thing Hamas wants, however, is to have a state given to them by Israel. But the real question is, why does the media refer to Israeli operation as an invasion, and the Sri Lankan operation as just that, an operation? Could it not have something to do with the fact that the US wants the Palestinians to have a… Read more »

Matt Downhour
Guest
Matt Downhour

And a quick note: the Jews were not shipped to Palestine. For 50 years there had been a movement to get them to learn Hebrew and sneak illegally into the British protectorate so they could someday lay claim to the land.

Bunny
Guest

All of my questions settled-thakns!

vjqjeuesx
Guest

GwFSp2 jzszrlfoepnb

jlvohjtji
Guest

Qf61jx , [url=http://vfumoyasrdvz.com/]vfumoyasrdvz[/url], [link=http://pgsdvcbhngna.com/]pgsdvcbhngna[/link], http://zltkawhqfscg.com/

kkhupjadwr
Guest

h6XCD2 bcponttwgeev

gbeilqm
Guest

quZYhJ , [url=http://prwfjvopdgsz.com/]prwfjvopdgsz[/url], [link=http://udobpyokkarh.com/]udobpyokkarh[/link], http://pfupoqrwexsx.com/

Support Our Work!

Poll

What would be the most appropriate nickname for Matt Rosendale?

Follow Us on Twitter

Subscribe Via E-mail

0 /* ]]> */