Montana Politics The Media US Politics

The Missoulian Offers Up Republican Propaganda on Immigration

Shares

Two caveats come to mind before discussing the latest diatribe offered up by the Missoulian editorial board:

1) Matt, Touchstone, and I need to committ to taking turns covering this tripe. Reading it too often cannot be good for the soul.

2) Does the RNC just mail its talking points to the editors?

Today's offering in the Missoulian suggests that states like Montana (you know, predominantly white states) lose representation in Congress and in the Electoral College because of the presence of illegal immigrants in states like Florida and California. The support for this claim comes from a group called the Center for Immigration Studies.

If that sounds like a reasonable, thoughtful think tank, their name has done the job. The truth is a bit less positive.

“Let’s be clear,” wrote Frank Sharry of the National Immigration Forum, “CIS was birthed by FAIR, the militant anti-immigration group. The CIS executive director moved from FAIR to CIS to head up the organization. Although now independent, the two organizations share the same basic agenda: an American version of what in Europe is called ‘zero immigration.’” According to Sharry, CIS masquerades as an objective, “squeaky clean” think tank, but CIS is “simply churning out high-sounding, low-credibility grist for the high-pitch, low-road anti-immigration forces in the United States.”

It seems hard to believe that responsible members of the media would just repeat wholesale what an agenda driven group says, doesn't it? Shouldn't it?

An article in the Wall Street Journal describes the group like this:

“CIS, FAIR, NumbersUSA, ProjectUSA—and more than a half-dozen similar groups that Republicans have become disturbingly comfortable with—were founded or funded (or both) by John Tanton. In addition to trying to stop immigration to the U.S., appropriate population control measures for Dr. Tanton and his network include promoting China’s one-child policy, sterilizing Third World women, and wider use of RU-486.”


And they favor sterilizing women in the Third World. Definitely a source oozing credibility. In the end, I don't mind that the editors at the Missoulian have an opinion that is different than mine; I just wish they would rely on argument to make it.

From that promising start, the editorial wanders off into wacky-land, asserting that the root of the problem is in the 3/5 Compromise of the Constitution. Brilliant insight again…

Finally, the editorial offers a tepid, baffling endorsement of a bill sponsored by Dennis "Porny" Rehberg that would count the number of citizens in a state, rather than the number of people. A brilliant plan, aside from the editorial's own admission that the Census Bureau cannot determine the legal status of people in the United States, and the crushing blow to social services in the states that do have large number of illegal immigrants.

To be fair, though, I'm sure that the editors of the Missoulian would not require these hard-working people to keep paying the taxes they pay.

Advertisements

Subscribe to our posts

Join a discussion of this (and all of our post) at our Facebook community page.

About the author

Don Pogreba

Don Pogreba is a eighteen-year teacher of English, former debate coach, and loyal, if often sad, fan of the San Diego Padres and Portland Timbers. He spends far too many hours of his life working at school and on his small business, Big Sky Debate.

His work has appeared in Politico and Rewire.

In the past few years, travel has become a priority, whether it’s a road trip to some little town in Montana or a museum of culture in Ísafjörður, Iceland.

4 Comments

Click here to post a comment
  • Supporters of Immigration Fraud

    An immigration advocacy group called “Civil Society Helps” and attorney Martha J Sullivan help perpetuate fraud against U.S. citizens. See http://www.marthasullivanlaw.com for more information about the immigration fraud these kind of groups help facilitate.

    With false accusations from an immigrant residency seeker, a stable American citizen can be reduced to living in poverty. All of your assets can be seized and given to the residency seeker even if you are not found guilty. You will immediately be forced to surrender a portion of your income to the residency seeker. The courts may order you to turn your motor vehicle over to the residency seeker even if the car is in your name and the residency seeker does not have a drivers license. Your immigrant spouse becomes legal and you become illegal. The court system will abuse you and strip you of your rights while social programs that promote immigration fraud thrive.

    Attorney Martha J. Sullivan – VAWA and Immigration Advocate
    (651) 438-9992
    1317 Vermillion St
    Hastings, MN 55033
    Web: http://www.marthasullivanlaw.com

    Civil Society Helps – Immigration Advocacy Group
    1st National Bank Building
    332 Minnesota St,
    Suite E-1436
    Saint Paul, MN 55101
    Phone: (651) 291-0713
    Fax: (651) 291-2588
    Web: http://civilsocietyhelps.org

    Stop Immigration Fraud!

/* ]]> */